Family Therapy
Full Title: Family Therapy: An Intimate History
Author / Editor: Lynn Hoffman
Publisher: W.W. Norton, 2001
Review © Metapsychology Vol. 7, No. 39
Reviewer: Patricia Ferguson, Psy.D.
Author
and family therapist Lynn Hoffman traces her journey as a therapist from 1963
to the present. The theme of this 294-page book is how the different
transitional persuasions have determined her view of and role as a family
therapist. As she notes, the field of family therapy closely parallels the
historical models of therapy in general. Different models developed out of the
culture or milieu in which it was being practiced.
After briefly reviewing the
historical models the therapeutic field went through, Hoffman points out one
possibility for the therapist is to "set aside the models." (In my
opinion, experienced therapists use whatever works best for any given situation
with any given client, and I believe there was a study to prove that exact
statement several years ago, although I don’t have the reference handy).
Hoffman
talks about her experiences over the decades with more emphasis in the second
half of the book on what she believes is helpful to families and therapists.
For instance, she describes the "reflecting team," a group who is
involved in all intakes. A certain format is followed.
Hoffman
uses vignettes throughout the book to help describe the models she is talking
about, moving along a rather dry subject (models of therapy can only be
interesting for so long). Essentially, this is a book of the history of family
therapy, and more specifically, a personal journey. Her use of vignettes and
personal discussions of what goes on in the treatment makes what otherwise
might be a dry subject a more interesting one. The book takes the role of
therapist from one of an "instrumental…causal" to a more
"collaborative, communal one." Historically, the therapist’s role
went from "fixing a system in trouble" and defining the problem as
"maladaptive behavior" to "a dysfunctional family
structure." The therapist also changed perspective from being considered
outside the system and aloof and distancing, to various models where the
therapist is considered to be more than outside the system. Some more radical
models place the therapist within the family.
I
remember when I studied family therapy we focused more on Bowenian therapy, or
at least I did. I found Bowen’s theory matched my personal beliefs of what
would work best. When it came time to write up a pass/fail test in my last
year, I used the Bowenian model for a female client who was a victim of
domestic violence. I also incorporated feminist theory, and whatever else I
found necessary or helpful. After graduating, I found Harriet Goldhor-Lerner’s
books, which didn’t even come out until I had graduated. Amazingly, she had
translated Bowenian theory into much more readable format. In private practice,
I typically use a combination of whatever applies to the family’s problems,
although some models don’t even say the family has problems, even if they are
in therapy for what they think are problems.
I
think anyone who is currently practicing family therapy should read this book,
if for no other reason than to learn about new models, new ways of approaching
helping families, and to make sure that the best possible ways of helping
families are being used. Teachers might want to consider this "required
reading" for their graduate students. It is beyond the level of
undergraduate studies, but certainly well worth the time to teach several
approaches in a very understandable way. It is not a textbook, but that makes
it easier reading. The combination of her personal and professional information
along with the vignettes makes this book a very good one for keeping abreast of
the field of family therapy.
© 2003 Patricia Ferguson
Patricia
Ferguson, PsyD is a licensed clinical psychologist, and freelance writer and
editor. She is Editor-in-Chief of Apolloslyre.com, and has most recently been
published in Girl Wars: 12 Strategies That End Female Bullying. She
specializes in women’s issues and is a book reviewer for several venues.
Categories: Psychotherapy